“The Internet of Bodies (IoBs) is an imminent extension to the vast Internet of Things domain, where interconnected devices (e.g., worn, implanted, embedded, swallowed, etc.) are located in-on-and-around the human body form a network. Thus, the IoB can enable a myriad of services and applications for a wide range of sectors, including medicine, safety, security, wellness, entertainment, to name but a few. Especially, considering the recent health and economic crisis caused by the novel coronavirus pandemic, also known as COVID-19, the IoB can revolutionize today’s public health and safety infrastructure. Nonetheless, reaping the full benefit of IoB is still subject to addressing related risks, concerns, and challenges. Hence, this survey first outlines the IoB requirements and related communication and networking standards. Considering the lossy and heterogeneous dielectric properties of the human body, one of the major technical challenges is characterizing the behavior of the communication links in-on-and-around the human body. Therefore, this article presents a systematic survey of channel modeling issues for various link types of human body communication (HBC) channels below 100 MHz, the narrowband (NB) channels between 400 and 2.5 GHz, and ultrawideband (UWB) channels from 3 to 10 GHz. After explaining bio-electromagnetics attributes of the human body, physical, and numerical body phantoms are presented along with electromagnetic propagation tool models. Then, the first-order and the second-order channel statistics for NB and UWB channels are covered with a special emphasis on body posture, mobility, and antenna effects. For capacitively, galvanically, and magnetically coupled HBC channels, four different channel modeling methods (i.e., analytical, numerical, circuit, and empirical) are investigated, and electrode effects are discussed. Finally, interested readers are provided with open research challenges and potential future research directions.”
Celik, A., Salama, K. N., & Eltawil, A. M.. (2022). The Internet of Bodies: A Systematic Survey on Propagation Characterization and Channel Modeling. IEEE Internet of Things Journal
“The internet of bodies (iobs) is an imminent extension to the vast internet of things domain, where interconnected devices (e.g., worn, implanted, embedded, swallowed, etc.) are located in-on-and-around the human body form a network. thus, the iob can enable a myriad of services and applications for a wide range of sectors, including medicine, safety, security, wellness, entertainment, to name but a few. especially, considering the recent health and economic crisis caused by the novel coronavirus pandemic, also known as covid-19, the iob can revolutionize today’s public health and safety infrastructure. nonetheless, reaping the full benefit of iob is still subject to addressing related risks, concerns, and challenges. hence, this survey first outlines the iob requirements and related communication and networking standards. considering the lossy and heterogeneous dielectric properties of the human body, one of the major technical challenges is characterizing the behavior of the communication links in-on-and-around the human body. therefore, this article presents a systematic survey of channel modeling issues for various link types of human body communication (hbc) channels below 100 mhz, the narrowband (nb) channels between 400 and 2.5 ghz, and ultrawideband (uwb) channels from 3 to 10 ghz. after explaining bio-electromagnetics attributes of the human body, physical, and numerical body phantoms are presented along with electromagnetic propagation tool models. then, the first-order and the second-order channel statistics for nb and uwb channels are covered with a special emphasis on body posture, mobility, and antenna effects. for capacitively, galvanically, and magnetically coupled hbc channels, four different channel modeling methods (i.e., analytical, numerical, circuit, and empirical) are investigated, and electrode effects are discussed. finally, interested readers are provided with open research challenges and potential future research directions.”
Lee, M., Boudreaux, B., Chaturvedi, R., Romanosky, S., & Downing, B.. (2020). The Internet of Bodies: Opportunities, Risks, and Governance. The Internet of Bodies: Opportunities, Risks, and Governance
“The work described in this report was conducted as part of a fellowship awarded by the rand corporation’s center for global risk and security. this report describes emerging technologies, herein referred to as the internet of bodies; analyzes their benefits and risks; and suggests ways various stakeholders can balance those benefits and risks. this report should be of interest to the general public, internet of bodies and medical device makers, health-care providers, and policy decisionmakers. the research was conducted within the center for global risk and security between february 2019 and september 2019.”
Makitalo, N., Flores-Martin, D., Berrocal, J., Garcia-Alonso, J., Ihantola, P., Ometov, A., … Mikkonen, T.. (2020). The Internet of Bodies Needs a Human Data Model. IEEE Internet Computing
“Today, creating innovative internet of bodies solutions requires manually gathering the needed information from an increasing number of services and personal devices. in this article, we tackle this challenge by presenting human data model-a programming framework for combining information from several sources, performing computations over that information to high-level abstractions, and then providing these abstractions to proactively schedule computer-human interactions.”
Boddington, G.. (2021). The Internet of Bodies—alive, connected and collective: the virtual physical future of our bodies and our senses. AI and Society
“This paper is going to discuss, what will be called, ‘the internet of bodies’. our physical and virtual worlds are blending and shifting our understanding of three key areas: (1) our identities are diversifying, as they become hyper-enhanced and multi-sensory; (2) our collaborations are co-created, immersive and connected; (3) our innovations are diverse and inclusive. it is proposed that our bodies have finally become the interface.”
Blake, M. B., Kandasamy, N., Dustdar, S., & Liu, X.. (2020). Internet of Bodies/Internet of Sports. IEEE Internet Computing
“As healthcare solutions and augmented monitoring of human mobility overlap with the new concepts of the internet of things, an emerging area of interest leverages sensor networks that monitor personal health data and human activity. this special issue presents research innovation that address advances in this evolving paradigm of internet of bodies/internet of sports.”
Ray, P. P.. (2020). Intelligent Ingestibles: Future of Internet of Body. IEEE Internet Computing
“In this article, we first provide the basics of ingestibles. then, we provide a detailed survey on ingestibles as per their applicability in leveraging gastrointestinal disease detection, management, and treatment. next, we show how ingestibles could be related with the concept of internet of body. lastly, we discuss various key challenges and future directions to mitigate these issues.”
El-Khoury, M., & Arikan, C. L.. (2021). From the internet of things toward the internet of bodies: Ethical and legal considerations. Strategic Change
“The proliferation of the internet of things makes the gray area of ethics darker and lighter simultaneously, and the law is currently not construed to accompany the steady progression toward the internet of bodies. the internet of things is challenging the traditional construct of ownership, and users are progressively losing control over their iot devices. the internet of bodies is the awaiting new normal where human bodies and minds form a connected network pervaded by the internet. the integrity of human bodies will rely more and more on the internet. in this context, the future calls for a balance between divergent interests of appealing technological progress and vital human safety.”
Peng, B., Fan, H., Wang, W., Dong, J., & Lyu, S.. (2021). A Unified Framework for High Fidelity Face Swap and Expression Reenactment. IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems for Video Technology
“Face manipulation techniques improve fast with the development of powerful image generation models. two particular face manipulation methods, namely face swap and expression reenactment attract much attention for their flexibility and ease to generate high quality synthesis results. recently, these two subjects are actively studied. however, most existing methods treat the two tasks separately, ignoring their underlying similarity. in this paper, we propose to tackle the two problems within a unified framework that achieves high quality synthesis results. the enabling component for our unified framework is the clean disentanglement of 3d pose, shape, and expression factors and then recombining them for different tasks accordingly. we then use the same set of 2d representations for face swap and expression reenactment tasks that are input to a common image translation model to directly generate the final synthetic images. once trained, the proposed model can accomplish both face swap and expression reenactment tasks for previously unseen subjects. comprehensive experiments and comparisons show that the proposed method achieves high fidelity results in multiple aspects, and it is especially good at faithfully preserving source facial shape in the face swap task, and accurately transferring facial movements in the expression reenactment task.”
Zhang, W., Zhao, C., & Li, Y.. (2020). A novel counterfeit feature extraction technique for exposing face-swap images based on deep learning and error level analysis. Entropy
“The quality and efficiency of generating face-swap images have been markedly strengthened by deep learning. for instance, the face-swap manipulations by deepfake are so real that it is tricky to distinguish authenticity through automatic or manual detection. to augment the efficiency of distinguishing face-swap images generated by deepfake from real facial ones, a novel counterfeit feature extraction technique was developed based on deep learning and error level analysis (ela). it is related to entropy and information theory such as cross-entropy loss function in the final softmax layer. the deepfake algorithm is only able to generate limited resolutions. therefore, this algorithm results in two different image compression ratios between the fake face area as the foreground and the original area as the background, which would leave distinctive counterfeit traces. through the ela method, we can detect whether there are different image compression ratios. convolution neural network (cnn), one of the representative technologies of deep learning, can extract the counterfeit feature and detect whether images are fake. experiments show that the training efficiency of the cnn model can be significantly improved by the ela method. in addition, the proposed technique can accurately extract the counterfeit feature, and therefore achieves outperformance in simplicity and efficiency compared with direct detection methods. specifically, without loss of accuracy, the amount of computation can be significantly reduced (where the required floating-point computing power is reduced by more than 90%).”
Korshunova, I., Shi, W., Dambre, J., & Theis, L.. (2017). Fast Face-Swap Using Convolutional Neural Networks. In Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Computer Vision
“We consider the problem of face swapping in images, where an input identity is transformed into a target identity while preserving pose, facial expression and lighting. to perform this mapping, we use convolutional neural networks trained to capture the appearance of the target identity from an unstructured collection of his/her photographs. this approach is enabled by framing the face swapping problem in terms of style transfer, where the goal is to render an image in the style of another one. building on recent advances in this area, we devise a new loss function that enables the network to produce highly photorealistic results. by combining neural networks with simple pre- and post-processing steps, we aim at making face swap work in real-time with no input from the user.”
Senses, M., & Topal, C.. (2019). Real time face swap based on patch warping. In 27th Signal Processing and Communications Applications Conference, SIU 2019
“Face swap is one of the popular machine vision problems recently. important problems in real-time face swap are the need for high computation power and the decrease in success of applications in case of face pose variations. in this paper, an original face swap algorithm which can work in real time is proposed. after detecting two faces in the input image, 68 landmark points of each face are localized. using these points, a facial model has been formed which separates the faces into 23 quadrilateral planar regions. homographies are calculated between the quadrilaterals formed by the same points on both sides in order not to disrupt the holistic structure of the selected regions. face swap is performed by warping the face patches with calculated homographies. with the proposed method, the calculation resources used in the algorithm have been used efficiently and identity information such as eye, mustache and eyebrow has been preserved. the symmetries of the visible regions are used for the invisible parts in the viewing angles that the camera cannot see the entire face. the success of our study has been tested with different camera resolutions and faces at different angles and qualitative results are given.”
Mahajan, S., Chen, L. J., & Tsai, T. C.. (2017). SwapItUp: A face swap application for privacy protection. In Proceedings – International Conference on Advanced Information Networking and Applications, AINA
“There is a growing concern over the issues related to online privacy due to large availability of high quality images. to tackle the privacy concerns a face swapping application is proposed. there is a library of face images, which is created by downloading images from different sources on internet. for any given image, first of all facial landmarks are detected. the second image is rotated and scaled so that it can properly fit over the input image. to make sure that the new image looks natural, color balance adjustment is done. after that blending of features from the second image onto the input image is done. it is also shown how this system can be used to creating appealing and funny photographs for entertainment purposes. we conclude with a study that shows the high quality of images produced by this system as compared to existing face swap applications and also limitations of this system.”
Sadu, C., & Das, P. K.. (2020). Swapping face images based on augmented facial landmarks and its detection. In IEEE Region 10 Annual International Conference, Proceedings/TENCON
“Facial landmark points that are precisely extracted from the face images improve the performance of many applications in the domains of computer vision and graphics. face swapping is one of such applications. with the availability of sophisticated image editing tools and the use of deep learning models, it is easy to create swapped face images or face swap attacks in images or videos even for non-professionals. face swapping transfers a face from a source to a destination image, while preserving photo realism. it has potential applications in computer games, privacy protection, etc. however, it could also be used for fraudulent purposes. in this paper, we propose an approach to create face swap attacks and detect them from the original images. the augmented 81-facial landmark points are extracted for creating the face swap attacks. the feature descriptors weighted local magnitude patterns (wlmp) and support vector machines (svm) are utilized for the swapped face images detection. the performance of the proposed approach is demonstrated by different types of svm classifiers on a real-world dataset. experimental results show that the proposed system effectively does face swapping and detection with an accuracy of 95%.”
Zhao, Y., Tang, F., Dong, W., Huang, F., & Zhang, X.. (2019). Joint face alignment and segmentation via deep multi-task learning. Multimedia Tools and Applications
“Face alignment and segmentation are challenging problems which have been extensively studied in the field of multimedia. these two tasks are closely related and their learning processes are supposed to benefit each other. hence, we present a joint multi-task learning algorithm for both face alignment and segmentation using deep convolutional neural network (cnn). the proposed multi-task learning approach allows cnn model to simultaneously share visual knowledge between different tasks. with a carefully designed refinement residual module, the cross-layer features are fused in a collaborative manner. to the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that face alignment and segmentation are learned together via deep multi-task learning. our experiments show that learning these two related tasks simultaneously builds a synergy between them, improves the performance of each individual task, and rivals recent approaches. furthermore, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our model in two practical applications: virtual makeup and face swap.”
Chawla, R.. (2019). Deepfakes: How a pervert shook the world. International Journal of Advance Research and Development
Show/hide publication abstract
“Recently a machine learning based open source software (i.e. a free to use the software) tool has made it easy to create hyper-realistic face swaps in videos that leave little to no traces of manipulation, in what is known as ‘deepfake’ videos. scenarios, where these ai manipulated/generated videos, are used for political distress, blackmail or even terrorism are easily envisioned as a near dystopia. this paper explores the various aspects of deepfake videos including its consequences and newly developed innovations in detecting deepfakes.”
Jiang, J., Li, B., Wei, B., Li, G., Liu, C., Huang, W., … Yu, M.. (2021). FakeFilter: A cross-distribution Deepfake detection system with domain adaptation. Journal of Computer Security
“Abuse of face swap techniques poses serious threats to the integrity and authenticity of digital visual media. more alarmingly, fake images or videos created by deep learning technologies, also known as deepfakes, are more realistic, high-quality, and reveal few tampering traces, which attracts great attention in digital multimedia forensics research. to address those threats imposed by deepfakes, previous work attempted to classify real and fake faces by discriminative visual features, which is subjected to various objective conditions such as the angle or posture of a face. differently, some research devises deep neural networks to discriminate deepfakes at the microscopic-level semantics of images, which achieves promising results. nevertheless, such methods show limited success as encountering unseen deepfakes created with different methods from the training sets. therefore, we propose a novel deepfake detection system, named fakefilter, in which we formulate the challenge of unseen deepfake detection into a problem of cross-distribution data classification, and address the issue with a strategy of domain adaptation. by mapping different distributions of deepfakes into similar features in a certain space, the detection system achieves comparable performance on both seen and unseen deepfakes. further evaluation and comparison results indicate that the challenge has been successfully addressed by fakefilter.”
Mirsky, Y., & Lee, W.. (2021). The Creation and Detection of Deepfakes. ACM Computing Surveys
“Generative deep learning algorithms have progressed to a point where it is difficult to tell the difference between what is real and what is fake. in 2018, it was discovered how easy it is to use this technology for unethical and malicious applications, such as the spread of misinformation, impersonation of political leaders, and the defamation of innocent individuals. since then, these ‘deepfakes’have advanced significantly. in this article, we explore the creation and detection of deepfakes and provide an in-depth view as to how these architectures work. the purpose of this survey is to provide the reader with a deeper understanding of (1) how deepfakes are created and detected, (2) the current trends and advancements in this domain, (3) the shortcomings of the current defense solutions, and (4) the areas that require further research and attention.”
Zhang, W., & Zhao, C.. (2019). Exposing Face-Swap Images Based on Deep Learning and ELA Detection. Proceedings
“New developments in artificial intelligence (ai) have significantly improved the quality and efficiency in generating fake face images; for example, the face manipulations by deepfake are so realistic that it is difficult to distinguish their authenticity—either automatically or by humans. in order to enhance the efficiency of distinguishing facial images generated by ai from real facial images, a novel model has been developed based on deep learning and error level analysis (ela) detection, which is related to entropy and information theory, such as cross-entropy loss function in the final softmax layer, normalized mutual information in image preprocessing, and some applications of an encoder based on information theory. due to the limitations of computing resources and production time, the deepfake algorithm can only generate limited resolutions, resulting in two different image compression ratios between the fake face area as the foreground and the original area as the background, which leaves distinctive artifacts. by using the error level analysis detection method, we can detect the presence or absence of different image compression ratios and then use convolution neural network (cnn) to detect whether the image is fake. experiments show that the training efficiency of the cnn model can be significantly improved by using the ela method. and the detection accuracy rate can reach more than 97% based on cnn architecture of this method. compared to the state-of-the-art models, the proposed model has the advantages such as fewer layers, shorter training time, and higher efficiency.”
Yan, S., He, S., Lei, X., Ye, G., & Xie, Z.. (2018). Video Face Swap Based on Autoencoder Generation Network. In ICALIP 2018 – 6th International Conference on Audio, Language and Image Processing
“Video facial swap usually has strong entertainment applications, and it is also applicable for the post-production of films and has great application value. at present, the popular face swap is done manually by the ps software, and the synthetic effect of the automatic face changing technology is not good. in order to make up for the lack of these features, this paper proposes a method of video face swap based on autoencoder generation network. the network learns the mapping relationship between distorted face and original face: the encoder can distinguish and extract facial information, and the decoder can restore face separately. first, the local information of tow face is sent to the network to get the initial model; then, the global information is put into the network for fine-tuning; finally, the face exchange between a and b is completed with face alignment and alpha fusion. the experimental results show that the quality of the method is improved significantly.”
“Deepfakes are a recent off-the-shelf manipulation technique that allows anyone to swap two identities in a single video. in addition to deepfakes, a variety of gan-based face swapping methods have also been published with accompanying code. to counter this emerging threat, we have constructed an extremely large face swap video dataset to enable the training of detection models, and organized the accompanying deepfake detection challenge (dfdc) kaggle competition. importantly, all recorded subjects agreed to participate in and have their likenesses modified during the construction of the face-swapped dataset. the dfdc dataset is by far the largest currently and publicly available face swap video dataset, with over 100,000 total clips sourced from 3,426 paid actors, produced with several deepfake, gan-based, and non-learned methods. in addition to describing the methods used to construct the dataset, we provide a detailed analysis of the top submissions from the kaggle contest. we show although deepfake detection is extremely difficult and still an unsolved problem, a deepfake detection model trained only on the dfdc can generalize to real ‘in-the-wild’ deepfake videos, and such a model can be a valuable analysis tool when analyzing potentially deepfaked videos. training, validation and testing corpuses can be downloaded from ai.facebook.com/datasets/dfdc.”
Wöhler, L., Henningson, J. O., Castillo, S., & Magnor, M.. (2020). PEFS: A Validated Dataset for Perceptual Experiments on Face Swap Portrait Videos. In Communications in Computer and Information Science
“Videos obtained by current face swapping techniques can contain artifacts potentially detectable, yet unobtrusive to human observers. however, the perceptual differences between real and altered videos, as well as properties leading humans to classify a video as manipulated, are still unclear. thus, to support the research on perceived realism and conveyed emotions in face swap videos, this paper introduces a high-resolution dataset providing the community with the necessary sophisticated stimuli. our recording process has been specifically designed to focus on human perception research and entails three scenarios (text-reading, emotion-triggering, and free-speech). we assess the perceived realness of our dataset through a series of experiments. the results indicate that our stimuli are overall convincing, even for long video sequences. furthermore, we partially annotate the dataset with noticeable facial distortions and artifacts reported by participants.”
Bode, L., Lees, D., & Golding, D.. (2021). The Digital Face and Deepfakes on Screen. Convergence
Cole, S.. (2018). We Are Truly Fucked: Everyone Is Making AI-Generated Fake Porn Now. Motherboard
Show/hide publication abstract
“A user-friendly application has resulted in an explosion of convincing face-swap porn.”
Tolosana, R., Vera-Rodriguez, R., Fierrez, J., Morales, A., & Ortega-Garcia, J.. (2020). Deepfakes and beyond: A Survey of face manipulation and fake detection. Information Fusion
“The free access to large-scale public databases, together with the fast progress of deep learning techniques, in particular generative adversarial networks, have led to the generation of very realistic fake content with its corresponding implications towards society in this era of fake news. this survey provides a thorough review of techniques for manipulating face images including deepfake methods, and methods to detect such manipulations. in particular, four types of facial manipulation are reviewed: i) entire face synthesis, ii) identity swap (deepfakes), iii) attribute manipulation, and iv) expression swap. for each manipulation group, we provide details regarding manipulation techniques, existing public databases, and key benchmarks for technology evaluation of fake detection methods, including a summary of results from those evaluations. among all the aspects discussed in the survey, we pay special attention to the latest generation of deepfakes, highlighting its improvements and challenges for fake detection. in addition to the survey information, we also discuss open issues and future trends that should be considered to advance in the field.”
Baek, J. Y., Yoo, Y. S., & Bae, S. H.. (2020). Generative Adversarial Ensemble Learning for Face Forensics. IEEE Access
“The recent advance of synthetic image generation and manipulation methods allows us to generate synthetic face images close to real images. on the other hand, the importance of identifying the synthetic face images increases more and more to protect personal privacy from those. although some deep learning-based image forensic methods have been developed recently, it is still challenging to distinguish synthetic images generated by recent image generation and manipulation methods such as the deep fake, face2face, and face swap. to resolve this challenge, we propose a novel generative adversarial ensemble learning method. we train multiple discriminative and generative networks based on the adversarial learning. compared to the conventional adversarial learning, our method is however more focused on improving the discrimination ability rather than image generation one. to this end, we improve the discriminabilty by ensembling outputs from different two discriminators. in addition, we train two generators in order to generate general and hard synthetic images. by ensemble learning of all the generators and discriminators, we improve the discriminators by using the generated synthetic face images, and improve the generators by passing the combined feedback of the discriminators. on the faceforensics benchmark challenge, we thoroughly evaluate our methods by comparing the recent methods. we also provide the ablation study to prove the effectiveness and usefulness of our method.”
Kaur, S., Kumar, P., & Kumaraguru, P.. (2020). Deepfakes: temporal sequential analysis to detect face-swapped video clips using convolutional long short-term memory. Journal of Electronic Imaging
“Deepfake (a bag of ‘deep learning’ and ‘fake’) is a technique for human image synthesis based on artificial intelligence, i.e., to superimpose the existing (source) images or videos onto destination images or videos using neural networks (nns). deepfake enthusiasts have been using nns to produce convincing face swaps. deepfakes are a type of video or image forgery developed to spread misinformation, invade privacy, and mask the truth using advanced technologies such as trained algorithms, deep learning applications, and artificial intelligence. they have become a nuisance to social media users by publishing fake videos created by fusing a celebrity’s face over an explicit video. the impact of deepfakes is alarming, with politicians, senior corporate officers, and world leaders being targeted by nefarious actors. an approach to detect deepfake videos of politicians using temporal sequential frames is proposed. the proposed approach uses the forged video to extract the frames at the first level followed by a deep depth-based convolutional long short-term memory model to identify the fake frames at the second level. also the proposed model is evaluated on our newly collected ground truth dataset of forged videos using source and destination video frames of famous politicians. experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.”
Gu, S., Bao, J., Yang, H., Chen, D., Wen, F., & Yuan, L.. (2019). Mask-guided portrait editing with conditional gans. In Proceedings of the IEEE Computer Society Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition
“Portrait editing is a popular subject in photo manipulation.the generative adversarial network (gan) advances the generating of realistic faces and allows more face editing. in this paper, we argue about three issues in existing techniques: diversity, quality, and controllability for portrait synthesis and editing. to address these issues, we propose a novel end-to-end learning framework that leverages conditional gans guided by provided face masks for generating faces. the framework learns feature embeddings for every face component (e.g., mouth, hair, eye), separately, contributing to better correspondences for image translation, and local face editing. with the mask, our network is available to many applications, like face synthesis driven by mask, face swap+ (including hair in swapping), and local manipulation. it can also boost the performance of face parsing a bit as an option of data augmentation.”
Wen, L., & Xu, D.. (2019). Face Image Manipulation Detection. In IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering
“This paper proposes a cnn-based (convolutional neural network based) network to detect altered face picture, which can cover the most common face swap methods. the network uses an autoencoder which is pre-trained on the original images to reconstruct the input images. the reconstructed one and the input image are then processed by the srm filter which can extract the noise distribution of images. we then feed the minus result of two processed results into a cnn architecture to predict whether the input image is original or tampered. the model was trained and evaluated in faceforensics dataset and state-of-art face swap method. experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our network.”
Guera, D., & Delp, E. J.. (2019). Deepfake Video Detection Using Recurrent Neural Networks. In Proceedings of AVSS 2018 – 2018 15th IEEE International Conference on Advanced Video and Signal-Based Surveillance
“In recent months a machine learning based free software tool has made it easy to create believable face swaps in videos that leaves few traces of manipulation, in what are known as deepfake videos. scenarios where these realistic fake videos are used to create political distress, blackmail someone or fake terrorism events are easily envisioned. this paper proposes a temporal-aware pipeline to automatically detect deepfake videos. our system uses a convolutional neural network (cnn) to extract frame-level features. these features are then used to train a recurrent neural network (rnn) that learns to classify if a video has been subject to manipulation or not. we evaluate our method against a large set of deepfake videos collected from multiple video websites. we show how our system can achieve competitive results in this task while using a simple architecture.”
Hashmi, M. F., Ashish, B. K. K., Keskar, A. G., Bokde, N. D., Yoon, J. H., & Geem, Z. W.. (2020). An Exploratory Analysis on Visual Counterfeits Using Conv-LSTM Hybrid Architecture. IEEE Access
“In recent years, with the advancements in the deep learning realm, it has been easy to create and generate synthetically the face swaps from gans and other tools, which are very realistic, leaving few traces which are unclassifiable by human eyes. these are known as ‘Deepfakes’ and most of them are anchored in video formats. such realistic fake videos and images are used to create a ruckus and affect the quality of public discourse on sensitive issues; defaming one’s profile, political distress, blackmailing and many more fake cyber terrorisms are envisioned. this work proposes a microscopic-typo comparison of video frames. this temporal-detection pipeline compares very minute visual traces on the faces of real and fake frames using convolutional neural network (cnn) and stores the abnormal features for training. a total of 512 facial landmarks were extracted and compared. parameters such as eye-blinking lip-synch; eyebrows movement, and position, are few main deciding factors that classify into real or counterfeit visual data. the recurrent neural network (rnn) pipeline learns based on these features-fed inputs and then evaluates the visual data. the model was trained with the network of videos consisting of their real and fake, collected from multiple websites. the proposed algorithm and designed network set a new benchmark for detecting the visual counterfeits and show how this system can achieve competitive results on any fake generated video or image.”
Nagarajan, A., & Soghrati, S.. (2018). Conforming to interface structured adaptive mesh refinement: 3D algorithm and implementation. Computational Mechanics
“A new non-iterative mesh generation algorithm named conforming to interface structured adaptive mesh refinement (cisamr) is introduced for creating 3d finite element models of problems with complex geometries. cisamr transforms a structured mesh composed of tetrahedral elements into a conforming mesh with low element aspect ratios. the construction of the mesh begins with the structured adaptive mesh refinement of elements in the vicinity of material interfaces. an r-adaptivity algorithm is then employed to relocate selected nodes of nonconforming elements, followed by face-swapping a small fraction of them to eliminate tetrahedrons with high aspect ratios. the final conforming mesh is constructed by sub-tetrahedralizing remaining nonconforming elements, as well as tetrahedrons with hanging nodes. in addition to studying the convergence and analyzing element-wise errors in meshes generated using cisamr, several example problems are presented to show the ability of this method for modeling 3d problems with intricate morphologies.”
Gerstner, E.. (2020). Face/off:” DeepFake” face swaps and privacy laws. Def. Counsel J.
Show/hide publication abstract
“… detect various prohibited content such as copyright violations, it would not be too complicated to add face swap detection as well to the bots which scan each and every post uploaded to their servers.the final potential target of legislation would be the software used to create …”
In this article, we analyze newspaper articles and advertisements mentioning vaccination from 1915 to 1922 and refer to historical studies of vaccination practices and attitudes in the early 20th century in order to assess historical continuities and discontinuities in vaccination concern. In the Progressive Era period, there were a number of themes or features that resonated with contemporary issues and circumstances: 1) fears of vaccine contamination; 2) distrust of medical professionals; 3) resistance to compulsory vaccination; and 4) the local nature of vaccination concern. Such observations help scholars and practitioners understand vaccine skepticism as longstanding, locally situated, and linked to the sociocultural contexts in which vaccination occurs and is mandated for particular segments of the population. A rhetorical approach offers a way to understand how discourses are engaged and mobilized for particular purposes in historical contexts. Historically situating vaccine hesitancy and addressing its articulation with a particular rhetorical ecology offers scholars and practitioners a robust understanding of vaccination concerns that can, and should, influence current approaches to vaccination skepticism.
Hausman, B. L., Ghebremichael, M., Hayek, P., & Mack, E.. (2014). ‘poisonous, filthy, loathsome, damnable stuff’: The rhetorical ecology of vaccination concern. Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine
Show/hide publication abstract
“In this article, we analyze newspaper articles and advertisements mentioning vaccination from 1915 to 1922 and refer to historical studies of vaccination practices and attitudes in the early 20th century in order to assess historical continuities and discontinuities in vaccination concern. in the progressive era period, there were a number of themes or features that resonated with contemporary issues and circumstances: 1) fears of vaccine contamination; 2) distrust of medical professionals; 3) resistance to compulsory vaccination; and 4) the local nature of vaccination concern. such observations help scholars and practitioners understand vaccine skepticism as longstanding, locally situated, and linked to the sociocultural contexts in which vaccination occurs and is mandated for particular segments of the population. a rhetorical approach offers a way to understand how discourses are engaged and mobilized for particular purposes in historical contexts. historically situating vaccine hesitancy and addressing its articulation with a particular rhetorical ecology offers scholars and practitioners a robust understanding of vaccination concerns that can, and should, influence current approaches to vaccination skepticism.”
Beginning at age thirteen, Karen Wetmore was subjected to horrific treatment in Vermont State Hospital and related facilities. Through years of investigative journalism, and numerous Freedom of Information Act requests, she was able do document that she was a victim of secret CIA mind control experiments as an adolescent, and of sexual abuse by one of her psychiatrists. Karen’s psychiatrists included Robert Hyde, M.D., who was cleared at TOP SECRET as the contractor on CIA LSD experiments conducted under MKULTRA Subprojects 8, 10, 63, and 66. Karen calls for an investigation into the nearly 3000 deaths at Vermont State Hospital from 1952 to 1973, when CIA money was pouring into the hospital. These deaths may have provided cover for terminal experiments conducted at the hospital.
—
Download: libgen.gs/ads.php?md5=6baf567aebc17a0b20983b867ca2add8
In 1933 Meerloo began to study the methods by which systematic mental pressure brings people to abject submission, and by which totalitarians imprint their subjective “truth” on their victims’ minds. In “The Rape of the Mind” he goes far beyond the direct military implications of mental torture to describing how our own culture unobtrusively shows symptoms of pressurizing people’s minds. He presents a systematic analysis of the methods of brainwashing and mental torture and coercion, and shows how totalitarian strategy, with its use of mass psychology, leads to systematized “rape of the mind.” He describes the new age of cold war with its mental terror, verbocracy, and semantic fog, the use of fear as a tool of mass submission and the problem of treason and loyalty, so loaded with dangerous confusion. The “Rape of the Mind” is written for the interested layman, not only for experts and scientists.
Contents:
Part One: The Techniques of Individual Submission.
1. You Too Would Confess.
2. Pavlov’s Students as Circus Tamers.
3. Medication into Submission.
4. Why Do They Yield? The Psychodynamics of False Confession.
Part Two: The Techniques of Mass Submission.
5. The Cold War against the Mind.
6. Totalitaria and its Dictatorship.
7. The Intrusion by Totalitarian Thinking.
8. Trial by Trial.
9. Fear as a Tool of Terror.
Part Three: Unobtrusive Coercion.
10. The Child is Father to the Man.
11. Mental Contagion and Mass Delusion.
12. Technology Invades Our Minds.
13. Intrusion by the Administrative Mind.
14. The Turncoat in Each of Us. Part Four: In Search of Defenses.
@book{book:{91532088},
title = {Operation Mind Control},
author = {Walter Bowart},
isbn = {0440167558; 9780440167556},
year = {1978},
url = {libgen.li/file.php?md5=5b759b56e154df6303bb47b051dfb3db}}
This text is an excerpt from a chapter of Bärtås and Ekman’s collection of essays Orienterarsjukan och andra berättelser.
URL: biblioteket.stockholm.se/titel/516229
—
The letter from Professor Delgado carries two insignias. One is made of Hebrew letters on what looks like a Torah scroll. Under the scroll it says “lux et veritas”—light and truth. The other insignia reads “Investigacion Ramon y Cajal.” In our letter to him, we have explained that we are two artists who have been studying his “astonishing research,” and that we are interested in his views on the relationship between humans and machines. José M.R. Delgado has written that he will be most happy to receive us at his home in Madrid.
Delgado’s name is a constant on various conspiracy websites dedicated to the topic of mind control; those with names like The Government Psychiatric Torture Site, Mind Control Forum, and Parascope. The Internet has in fact become the medium of conspiracy theorists. The network functions as an endless library where the very web structure lends itself to a conspiratorial frame of mind. The idea that every phenomenon and person can be connected to another phenomenon and person is the seed of the conspiracy theorist’s claim to “make the connections between things,” track the flow of power, and show how everything hangs together within some larger murky context.
Before traveling to Madrid, we get a hold of Physical Control of the Mind: Toward a Psychocivilized Society, the 1969 Delgado book most often cited on the Net. The book has has been gathering dust for 30 years at the university’s psychology library: it has never been cracked open. It is a disturbing book, less because of its photographs of animal experiments than because of the triumphal tone of the writing. Delgado discusses how we have managed to tame and civilize our surrounding nature. Now it is time to civilize our inner being. The scientist sees himself on the verge of a new era where humans will undergo “psycho-civilization” by linking their brains directly to machines.
“Ramon y Cajal”—the name on one of the two insignia—is referred to in Delgado’s book. Cajal was a famous histologist who became the young Delgado’s mentor and inspiration. In his acknowledgements, Delgado cites Cajal’s telling claim that “knowledge of the physicochemical basis of memory, feelings, and reason would make man the true master of creation, that his most transcendental accomplishment would be the conquering of his own brain.”1
Professor Delgado is now 85 and lives in a suburb of Madrid. Madrid is also the home of an anonymous group of people who call themselves Nosman, and are dedicated to gathering information about Delgado and his career. We e-mail Nosman and receive some awkwardly written responses that oscillate between warnings about the Spanish security agencies and suspicious questions about us and our interest in Delgado. For some reason, they refuse to meet with us but give us Delgado’s email address anyway. Delgado, on the other hand, responds immediately when we get to Madrid. He is very eager to invite us to lunch.
It was at Madrid University that Delgado began his research on pain and pleasure as the means of behavior control. After World War II, he became the head of the Department of neuropsychiatry at Yale’s medical school. In 1966, he became a professor in physiology. By that time, he had further developed the research of the Swiss physiologist and Nobel Prize winner Walter Rudolph Hess who had used electric stimulation to chart how different parts of the brain control different motor functions.
After a series of spectacular experiments on animals in Bermuda, Delgado wrote: “If you insert electrodes directly into the brains of cats and apes, they will behave like electronic toys. A whole series of motor functions can be triggered based on which button the experimenter pushes. This applies to all body parts: front and back paws, the tail, the hind parts, the head, and the ears.”
Using electrostimulation in a group of gibbon apes, Delgado succeeded in dismantling the usual power structure within the group. He gave a female ape with a low ranking a control box connected to electrodes that were implanted in the group’s alpha male, and the female learned to use the box to turn the alpha male on and off at will.
The electrodes were inserted into the ape’s brain and connected to an instrument that Delgado called the stimoceiver. The stimoceiver was an ideal instrument for two-way communication. Researchers could affect and at the same time register activity in the brain. From earlier prototypes where the lab animals were connected with wires, a remote control model was later developed that could send and receive signals over FM waves. The device was developed from the telemetric equipment used to send signals to and from astronauts in space. “We have already established radio contact with space; it is now time to establish contact with the human brain,”—a recurring refrain in Delgado’s articles.
The taxi lets us out in an upscale suburb of Madrid where a light rain is falling on the brick houses. A church service has just finished and people in Burberry clothes are streaming out of a strange concrete church. At the entrance of the apartment building where Delgado lives, we are met by a fashionable and exuberant American woman of indeterminable age. The woman, who is Delgado’s wife, talks nonstop in the elevator that opens directly into the apartment. The apartment is decorated in a fussy, bourgeois style. If it were not such a bleak day, the view would extend all the way to the Pardo Mountains. Delgado gives us a very cordial welcome. He is a proper old gentleman with sharp, intelligent eyes.
Delgado says that he has had a nightmare about our visit and woke up crying in the middle of the night. In the dream, we had showed up barefoot and in short sleeve shirts and had proceeded to gulp down all of his meringues. An hour later, we are seated at the marble table in his dining room and are served meringues and strawberry tarts after a large meal. We do not want to have more than one meringue each.
In a CNN special from 1985 called “Electro-magnetic Weapons and Mind Control,” the reporter claims that Delgado’s experiments were limited to animals. Nor is there anything in the texts on the various websites that indicates how far Delgado went in his research. His experiments on humans seem to have fallen into a strange collective amnesia. But anyone can walk into any well-stocked American medical library and take out Delgado’s own reports and articles on the subject. There we can find his own candid, open descriptions of how he moved on from experimenting on animals to humans. In an article called “Radio Control Behavior” in the February 1969 issue of The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, Delgado, Dr. Mark, and several other colleagues describe what was the first clinical use of Intracerebral Radio Stimulation (IRS) on a human being. The stimoceiver itself only weighed 70 grams and was held fast by a bandage. One of the patients hid her stimoceiver with a wig because the experiments lasted days or weeks. The patients were scrutinized thoroughly. Everything they said was taped, their EEG was recorded, and they were photographed at regular intervals in order to document changes in their facial expressions.
In one of the article’s photographs, we see two of the subjects engaged in “spontaneous activity.” They are both girls with bandages over their heads. The girl in the background is holding something to her mouth, perhaps a harmonica. The other girl is bent over a guitar. Delgado’s colleague, Dr. Mark, is smiling at them. Mark had already achieved some notoriety at this time by claiming that all anti-social behavior is caused by brain damage. His recommendation had been the mass scanning of the American population in order to detect such damage in time and “correct” it.
Delgado and Mark’s article offers short descriptions of the patients who have had the device affixed to their brain. A black fourteen-year-old girl on the border of developmental disability who grew up in a foster home suddenly goes into a fury that leads to the death of her two stepsisters. A thirty-five-year old white industrial designer who ends up killing his wife and children flies into a rage when other motorists try to overtake him and he chases them and tries to run them off the road. Their aggressive behavior is supposed to be registered by the stimoceiver in the way a seismograph registers the earth’s tremors and the same stimoceiver is then to “turn them off” via the FM transmitter.
Delgado bombards us with a steady stream of anecdotes, scientific comments, and provocative rhetorical questions that are only interrupted by occasional tender comments directed to his wife. He tells of his work at the Ramon y Cajal Institute in the 1930s. In order to save a few paltry pennies, he would take a short cut through the zoo on his way to and from work. He would wander through the zoo alone at dawn and dusk and would hear lions and tigers roaring in this jungle in the city. After the War, he came to conquer nature in his own way in Bermuda. Even his wife was delighted to see the alpha male gibbon collapse when the underlings pushed the control lever. “Do you remember how we thought of Franco?” says his wife. “Imagine being able to turn off the Generalisimo.” Delgado responds “But who could have put the electrodes into the dictator? With electromagnetic radiation we could have controlled the dictator from a distance. We did some experiments at Yale where we influenced the brain from up to 30 meters away.”
One of the most important reasons why we wanted to meet Delgado is that we imagined him and his activities as belonging to a borderland between fiction and reality, between science and madness. People in psychotic states of mind often feel themselves controlled by foreign voices or spend their lives trying to prove that they have had a transmitter implanted inside their skulls that dictates their actions and thoughts all day and night. We ask Delgado what he thinks of the fact that his research provides a realistic edge to such fantasies.
He answers that he has on several occasions been contacted by strangers who say they want to have their implants removed and also that he has been sued by people he has never seen. Delgado is silent about the article that appeared in the Spanish monthly magazine Tiempo last year, where he was interviewed about exactly such accusations. The Tiempo reporter claimed that Delgado has ties with the Spanish secret police.
Delgado stretches out after the strawberry tarts. He has come to think of a case in Pittsburg in the 1950s where a robber was offered a milder sentence in exchange for being lobotomized. “I was operating electrodes into people’s brains at that time together with my good friend David Koskoff.” It was Koskoff who carried out the lobotomy on the robber. The patient was quiet for a while after the operation but then reverted to carrying out robberies again. In despair over his own unreliability, he decided to take his own life. He wrote a suicide note addressed to Dr. Koskoff: “Doctor, all your work has been in vain. I am an incompetent man and a criminal. I am taking my life but I am shooting myself in the heart and not the head. I donate my brain to you for research.”
Delgado’s wife puts her arm on his shoulder and says “And very little has happened since then, dear. There are still lots of bums running around.” The comment makes us both look away.
A moment later, we are sitting on the sofa. Delgado admits that not one useful application of the stimoceiver has come out of his research. “We knew too little about the brain. It is much too complicated to be controlled. We never knew which parts of the brain we were stimulating with the stimoceiver. We didn’t even manage to prevent epileptic attacks, which we thought would be the simplest of things. We never found the area where epilepsy attacks originate.” He says all of this without a trace of bitterness, as if in passing.
We are surprised by his casual attitude toward the stimoceiver, which in the 1960s and 70s was heralded as a great contribution to science. To demonstrate the power of their invention, Delgado and his colleagues orchestrated violent scenes in the lab. In her book, The Brain Changers: Scientists and the New Mind Control, Maya Pine describes a film where Dr. Mark attaches a stimoceiver to an electrode in a woman’s brain:
As the film opens, the patient, a rather attractive young woman, is seen playing the guitar and singing “Puff, the Magic Dragon.” A psychiatrist sits a few feet away. She seems undisturbed by the bandages that cover her head like a tight hood, from her forehead to the back of her neck. Then a mild electric current is sent from another room, stimulating one of the electrodes in her right amygdala. Immediately, she stops singing, the brainwave tracings from her amygdala begin to show spikes, a sign of seizure activity. She stares blankly ahead. Suddenly she grabs her guitar and smashes it against the wall, narrowly missing the psychiatrist’s head.2
The same incident was described in one of Delgado’s own articles. This experiment was repeated three days in a row.
If there were any problems with the experiments for Delgado, these were not ethical in nature but technical. How do you replicate the lab situation in society? How do you cut off the electricity to the stimoceiver? How do you avoid scarring and inflammation where the stimoceiver enters the brain? But the problems did not provoke any doubts about the supposed success of the stimoceiver. In the long run, the technique could be used to make people happy from a distance.
“When did you stop the stimoceiver experiments?” we ask him. To our surprise, he responds indignantly that he has yet to do so. “After Yale, I have continued my experiments here in Spain, both on animals and on humans.” Delgado’s pragmatism does another pirouette and we are beginning to have trouble following him.
Delgado pours coffee with his trembling hands. Spanish guitar music from the stereo fills the silence. We look together through the three recent collection of essays that Delgado has placed in front of us. Their publication dates range from 1979 up to this year. There is no emphasis on neurophysiology in any of them. Instead, they address questions of learning and upbringing from a more general psychological point of view.
Until the end of the 70s, Delgado and his colleagues were considered conquerors of an unknown territory, a wild and expansive jungle, the landscape of the brain and the soul. Apparently Delgado never got very far into the jungle, which proved to be much too thick and impenetrable. He has apparently retired without any regrets. He has instead started to cultivate his own garden. “My new book is going to be called The Education of My Grandchildren and Myself.”
We ask if it is possible to learn to interpret the electrical language of the brain and mention the Swedish science journalist Göran Frankel’s interview with Delgado back in 1977.3 In the interview Delgado claims that it is only a question of time before we connect the brain directly into computers that can communicate with the brain’s electrical language.
Delgado makes a dismissive gesture and looks at us as if we are numskulls. “It is impossible to decode the brain’s language. We can obviously manipulate different forms of electrical activity but what does that prove?” When we ask him about his colleague, Dr. Robert G. Heath, who claimed to be able to cure schizophrenic patients with electrostimulation, Delgado breaks into a patronizing smile and says, “Yes, yes, you’re supposed to have a box on your stomach with cables coming out of it that attach to electrodes in your brain and you stimulate yourself. It never worked.”
We lead him to a discussion of his own patients. Delgado interrupts us: “I have never done experiments on people.” For a moment, we wonder if we’ll have to take out one of his own scientific articles and hold it in front of him as evidence. We start to look for our file with hundreds of medical reports and articles. “You have to understand,” he says. “There are incredibly stringent rules around experimenting on humans. All the experiments I was involved in had a therapeutic goal. They were for the patients’ best.”
In one of the Yale reports in our file, there is a description of an experiment on an epileptic mental patient. The report states that the woman has been in asylums for a long time, she is worried about her daughter, and suffers from economic hardship. Electrodes measuring 12 centimeters have been stuck into her brain, 5 centimeters of them inside the brain tissue. She is interviewed while being given periodic electrical stimulation. The woman is tossed between various emotional states and finds that strange words are coming to her mind. She experiences pain and sexual desire. At the end of the interview, she becomes flirty and her language becomes coarse, only to be ashamed later and ask to be excused for words that she felt had come to her from outside. The woman has been transformed into a speaking doll that unwillingly gives voice to her brain’s every whim.
Delgado, who had previously been so flattered by two artists being interested in his work, now seems to be looking at us with new eyes. Who are we? And what do we want? His tone is short and sharp. The temperature in the apartment has dropped a few degrees.
In Physical Control of the Mind, Delgado proudly sums up how he has “used electrodes implanted for days or months to block thought, speech, and movement, or to trigger joy, laughter, friendliness, verbal activity, generosity, fear, hallucinations, and memory.” With this in mind, we ask him what therapeutic results came from these experiments. “As a whole, they didn’t result in any methods, except in the case of patients with chronic pain.”
Delgado in his apartment in Madrid. Video still courtesy of Magnus Bärtås.
He looks at the clock and says that we only have five minutes left. But we do not want to abandon our questions about the patients. What happened to them? How long were the implants in their brains? Delgado now becomes somewhat vague. He says that it was other researchers that left the implants in for a long time, not him or Dr. Heath, and he does not recall which patients it was. The electrodes were taken out of his own patients after a couple of days and did not cause any injuries. “We killed maybe a few hundred neurons when we inserted the electrodes. But the brain has millions of neurons.”
When Delgado spoke in the 60s of “the precise interface between brain and machine,” it gave rise to a number of far-fetched military visions. His research was also mainly funded by military institutions such as the Office of Naval Research and the Air Force AeroMedical Research Laboratory.
In the US, the CIA and government research in (and use of) different means of behavior control was made public in a series of congressional hearings in 1974 as well as in a Senate investigation three years later. Witnesses offered a glimpse of the CIA’s astonishing experiments in the so-called MK-Ultra program. The list of MK-Ultra experiments is like a group photo of the extended family of behavioral technologies: hypnosis, drugs, psychological testing, sleep research, brain research, electromagnetism, lie detection. The specific operations had very imaginative names: Sleeping Beauty, Project Pandora, Woodpecker, Artichoke, Operation Midnight Climax.
One of MK-Ultra’s fields of interest was electromagnetic fields and their effect on human beings. In 1962 it was discovered that the Russians had directed microwave radiation at the American embassy in Moscow with the hope of penetrating through to the ambassador’s office. The CIA immediately mounted an investigation under the codename Project Pandora. Concurrently with his research on the stimoceiver, Delgado had begun research on electro-magnetic radiation and its capacity for influencing people’s consciousness, and there is speculation that Delgado may have been involved in Project Pandora.
The CIA arranged for apes to be brought to the embassy. When the apes were examined after a period of being radiated, it was discovered that they had undergone changes in their chromosomes and blood. The personnel at the embassy was later reported to have increased white blood cell counts of up to 40 percent. The Boston Globe reported that the ambassador himself suffered not only from bloody eyes and chronic headaches but also from a blood disease resembling leukemia.
We take up Delgado’s research on electromagnetic fields and their effect on people. “I could later do with electro-magnetic radiation what I did with the stimoceiver. It’s much better because there’s no need for surgery,” he explains. “I could make apes go to sleep. But I stopped that line of research fifteen years ago. But I’m sure they’ve done a lot more research on this in both the US and Russia.”
We understand now that Delgado thinks the meeting ought to come to an end. We ask him about Project Pandora and he confirms the story of the Moscow Signal without any hesitation but he denies being involved in the operation.
In 1972, an article citing Delgado’s views was presented at Congress’s MK-Ultra hearings:
We need a program of psychosurgery for political control of our society. The purpose is physical control of the mind. Everyone who deviates from the given norm can be surgically manipulated. The individual may think that the most important reality is his own existence, but this is only his personal point of view. This lacks historical perspective Man does not have the right to develop his own mind. This kind of liberal orientation has great appeal. We must electrically control the brain. Some day armies and generals will be controlled by electric stimulation of the brain.4
When we confront him with this statement, he falls silent for a second. His crystal-clear memory of a moment ago suddenly evaporates. A fog sweeps in, the words become hard to get out. He does not recall ever being called to Congress. And he has no desire to acknowledge the kinds of statements we have just mentioned. For a second, Delgado becomes a very old and fragile man. But in the next moment, he is standing up straight again and has shaken off all these unpleasantries. Now he is in a hurry. He has to meet his sick sister-in-law. We try to secure a second meeting but he is evasive and talks about the vagaries of the weather and trips to his country house. Out the door in a cloud of cigar smoke, the taxi takes us back to Madrid.
Translated by Sina Najafi
This article was corrected on 29 November 2014. Since publishing this article in Cabinet no. 2 (Spring 2001), several errors have come to our attention. Together, these support Delgado’s claim that he never appeared before Congress or made the statement that the authors attributed to him. Delgado never testified before Congress during the MK-Ultra hearings, which in fact took place not in 1974 but in 1977. Neither is his name present in any of the transcripts of the hearings. Additionally, as far as we have been able to determine, the cited statement does not exist in this form in any of Delgado’s publications, though some of the phrases do occur in his book Physical Control of the Mind. The sole reference to Delgado in the Congressional Record that we have been able to locate appears in Dr. Peter Breggin’s “The Return of Lobotomy and Psychosurgery.” This article, which was critical of Delgado’s methods, was entered into the Congressional Record on 24 February 1972. We regret the errors.
Schleim, S.. (2021). Neurorights in History: A Contemporary Review of José M. R. Delgado’s “Physical Control of the Mind” (1969) and Elliot S. Valenstein’s “Brain Control” (1973). Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 15
“Scholars from various disciplines discuss the ethical, legal, and social implications of neurotechnology. some have proposed four concrete ‘neurorights’. this review presents the research of two pioneers in brain stimulation from the 1950s to 1970s, josé m. r. delgado and elliot s. valenstein, who also reflected upon the ethical, legal, and social aspects of their and other scientists’ related research. delgado even formulated the vision ‘toward a psychocivilized society’ where brain stimulation is used to control, in particular, citizens’ aggressive and violent behavior. valenstein, by contrast, believed that the brain is not organized in such a way to allow the control or even removal of only negative processes without at the same time diminishing desirable ones. the paper also describes how animal and human experimentation on brain stimulation was carried out in that time period. it concludes with a contemporary perspective on the relevance of neurotechnology for neuroethics, neurolaw, and neurorights, including two recent examples for brain-computer interfaces.”
Vera, J. A., & Martínez-Sánchez, F.. (2016). Ethics, science and mind control: J. M. Rodríguez-Delgado’s legacy. Spanish Journal of Psychology
“This work analyses the evolution of the scientific visibility of the neurophysiologist josé manuel rodríguez delgado. it examines the longitudinal evolution from 1955 to 2013 of an article (delgado, roberts, & miller, 1954) studying the neurological basis of learning and motivation and compares it with a coetaneous article (olds & milner, 1954) with a similar subject and methodology. both studies have been essential in psychology. this work analyses the number of times each article has been cited between 1955-1984 and 1985-2013. the results show that the visibility of james olds and peter milner’s article (expressed in number of citations between 1955-1984 and 1985-2013) has longitudinally increased (p <.001), whereas the number of citations received by josé manuel rodríguez delgado et al.’s article has significantly reduced (p <.001). the results are discussed and the low visibility of delgado’s article is explained through historical and social factors, including the growing concern about compliance with bioethical and research guidelines and the controversial media projection of the spanish scientist, not by the intrinsic value or the scientific repercussion of the compared articles.”
Sultanov, M.. (2019). Brain-Computer Interfaces: From Past to Future. American Journal of Biomedical Science & Research
“More than 100 years ago, scientists were interested in the capabilities of the brain and tried to understand whether it is possible to somehow influence it. in 1875, english doctor richard caton managed to register a weak electric field on the surface of the brain of rabbits and monkeys. then there was a lot of discovery and research, but only in 1950, josé manuel rodríguez delgado, a professor of physiology at yale university, invented the device, which could be implanted in the brain and controlled by radio signals. ”
Wilder, J.. (1971). Physical Control of the Mind. Toward a Psychocivilized Society. American Journal of Psychotherapy
“Http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/jos%c3%a9_manuel_rodriguez_delgado josé manuel rodriguez delgado from wikipedia, the free encyclopedia jump to: navigation, search ‘jose delgado’ redirects here. for the comic book character, see gangbuster. text document with red question mark.svg tthis article includes a list of references, related reading or external links, but its sources remain unclear because it lacks inline citations. please improve this article by introducing more precise citations where appropriate. (may 2010) dr. josé manuel rodriguez delgado (born august 8, 1915) is a spanish professor of physiology at yale university, famed for his research into mind control through electrical stimulation of regions in the brain. contents [hide] * 1 biography * 2 research * 3 references * 4 further reading * 5 external links [edit] biography delgado was born in ronda, spain in 1915. he received a doctor of medicine degree from the university of madrid just before the outbreak of the spanish civil war, in which he served as a medical corpsman on the republican side. after the war he had to repeat his m.d. degree, and then took a ph.d. at the cajal institute in madrid. ”
Blackwell, B.. (2012). Jose Manuel Rodriguez Delgado. Neuropsychopharmacology
“Presents an obituary of jose manuel rodriguez delgado (1915-2011). jose enrolled in madrid medical school in 1933 to study both medicine and physiology. in 1936, the spanish civil war erupted, his mentor juan negri fled the country and jose joined the republican side as a medical corpsman. from 1942 to 1950, he began research in neurophysiology on selective brain ablation and electrical stimulation in animals, published 14 articles and won several prizes. in 1950, delgado won a scholarship to the yale university in the department of physiology under the direction of john fulton whose pioneer work on pre-frontal lobotomy in chimpanzees encouraged the portuguese psychiatrist egas moniz to perform the operation in schizophrenic patients, for which he received the noble prize in 1949. delgado positioned himself between growing disapproval of mutilating brain surgery and his own belief that electrical stimulation of specific brain areas was scientifically superior to oral administration of drugs whose effects were mitigated by liver metabolism, the blood-brain barrier, and uncertain distribution. in the last years of his life, jose and his wife returned to america and lived in san diego where he died unheralded. unjustly treated and harshly judged by segments of the public and his profession, jose delgado’s ground breaking research, benevolent philosophy, and memory deserve better recognition. his career trajectory may provide budding scientists with a cautionary note about the pitfalls of mingling science with philosophy. (psycinfo database record (c) 2016 apa, all rights reserved)”
Faria, M.. (2013). Violence, mental illness, and the brain – A brief history of psychosurgery: Part 3 – From deep brain stimulation to amygdalotomy for violent behavior, seizures, and pathological aggression in humans. Surgical Neurology International
“In the final installment to this three-part, essay-editorial on psychosurgery, we relate the history of deep brain stimulation (dbs) in humans and glimpse the phenomenal body of work conducted by dr. jose delgado at yale university from the 1950s to the 1970s. the inception of the national commission for the protection of human subjects of biomedical and behavioral research (1974-1978) is briefly discussed as it pertains to the ‘determination of the secretary of health, education and welfare regarding the recommendations and guidelines on psychosurgery.’ the controversial work – namely recording of brain activity, dbs, and amygdalotomy for intractable psychomotor seizures in patients with uncontrolled violence – conducted by drs. vernon h. mark and frank ervin is recounted. this final chapter recapitulates advances in neuroscience and neuroradiology in the evaluation of violent individuals and ends with a brief discussion of the problem of uncontrolled rage and ‘pathologic aggression’ in today’s modern society – as violence persists, and in response, we move toward authoritarianism, with less freedom and even less dignity.”
Marzullo, T. C.. (2017). The Missing Manuscript of Dr. Jose Delgado’s Radio Controlled Bulls.. Journal of Undergraduate Neuroscience Education : JUNE : A Publication of FUN, Faculty for Undergraduate Neuroscience
Show/hide publication abstract
“Neuroscience systems level courses teach: 1) the role of neuroanatomical structures of the brain for perception, movement, and cognition; 2) methods to manipulate and study the brain including lesions, electrophysiological recordings, microstimulation, optogenetics, and pharmacology; 3) proper interpretation of behavioral data to deduce brain circuit operation; and 4) the similarities, differences, and ethics of animal models and their relation to human physiology. these four topics come together quite dramatically in dr. jose delgado’s 1960s famous experiments on the neural correlates of aggression in which he stopped bulls in mid-charge by electrically stimulating basal ganglia and thalamic structures. technical documentation on these experiments is famously difficult to find. here i translate and discuss a spanish language article written by dr. delgado in 1981 for an encyclopedia on bull fighting published in madrid. here dr. delgado appears to give the most complete explanation of his experiments on microstimulation of bovine brains. dr. delgado’s motivations, methods, and his interpretation of the bull experiments are summarized, as well as some accompanying information from his 1970 english language book: ‘physical control of the mind.’ this review of dr. delgado’s written work on the bull experiments can provide a resource to educators and students who desire to learn more about and interpret the attention-calling experiments that dr. delgado did on a ranch in andalucía over 50 years ago.”
Zemelman, B. V.. (2017). Uncovering key neurons for manipulation in mammals. In Optogenetics: From Neuronal Function to Mapping and Disease Biology
“Introduction in one guise or another, directed manipulation of brain function can be traced back decades. while much has been made of francis crick’s musings in the 1990s on the potential power of selective neuronal stimulation (crick, 1999), remarkably effective – albeit controversial – in vivo experiments had been conducted by jose delgado nearly 30 years earlier. working with large mammals and primates, delgado demonstrated that many properties attributed to the primitive brain (maclean, 1990; panksepp, 2004) – sleep, nurture, hunger and aggression – could be modified by stimulating narrowly circumscribed groups of neurons, including by ‘remote control’ (delgado, 1964; delgado, 1969). these studies motivated ever more troubling attempts at psychosurgery in the form of localized electrical stimulation in order to diagnose, condition and treat human subjects suffering from behavioral and psychiatric disorders (heath, monroe and mickle, 1955; king, 1961; sweet, ervin and mark, 1969). current selective activation techniques, however, stem from efforts to image, rather than perturb, brain function. the advent of fluorescent protein-based cellular markers and reporters in the late 1990s represented a critical advance in combining the convenience of light with the precision of genetic encoding. such sensors helped catalyze our plan to design a method for stimulating neurons, as opposed to passively monitoring them. our 2001 overview of optical sensors ends with this prescient hypothesis: ‘… schemes [that] localize the response to illumination could [feed] patterns of distributed activity … directly into a genetically circumscribed population of neurons, irrespective of the anatomical location of its members or their connection to sensory input. perhaps the ability to probe defined groups of neurons with [light] will hold the key to an understanding of neural systems’ (zemelman and miesenböck, 2001). these sentences succinctly frame the revolution that would take place in experimental neuroscience over the following 15 years. while the tools for selective photoactivation of neurons have benefitted from numerous much-needed refinements, chief among them the cloning of channelrhodopsin (nagel et al., 2003), the prediction that light and a heterologous light receptor could be used to dissect neuronal mechanisms in vivo has been exhaustively validated across numerous systems and species.”
“The methods used for mass extermination in the nazi death camps originated and were perfected in earlier use against people with physical, emotional, and intellectual disabilities. this article describes the historical context of attitudes toward people with disabilities in germany and how this context produced mass murder of people with disabilities prior to and during the early years of world war ii. several key marker variables, the manipulation of which allowed a highly sophisticated western society to officially sanction the murder of people with disabilities, are examined. important implications must continually be drawn from these sad events as we work with people with disabilities at the dawn of a new century.”
Irmak, K. H.. (1998). Anstaltsfursorge fur “alterssieche” von Weimar bis Bonn (1924-1961). Zeitschrift Fur Gerontologie Und Geriatrie
“The article deals with the development of institutionalized care and its overall discourse concerning the elderly sick people in germany from 1924 to 1961. this period of time embraces an ambivalent process of modernization that falls short of any unilinear success story. neither politics nor the medical sciences had the impact to make the nursing homes catch up with the advanced hospitals. they became low-grade institutions within the national welfare system. these homes evolved from poor-law houses with no specialized care whatsoever. the chronically ill and infirm old people emerged during the 19th century not as the result of straight forward professionalization. the social hygiene in the weimar period and the racist paradigm of the nazi- period turned a blind eye to the chronically ill elderly people well into the era of the murderous ‘euthanasia’. at least in the second half of world war ii chronically sick old people were increasingly regarded as so called ‘useless eaters’ and, thus, doomed to be killed or starved to death. the mortality rate remained very high after the end of the war due to wide- spread hunger. the situation did not improve until 1948 and in the 50s this part of state welfare took advantage of the general expansion in the social and health care system.”
Allen, G. E.. (1997). The social and economic origins of genetic determinism: A case history of the American Eugenics Movement, 1900-1940 and its lessons for today. Genetica
“Eugenics, the attempt to improve the genetic quality of the human species by ‘better breeding’, developed as a worldwide movement between 1900 and 1940. it was particularly prominent in the united states, britain and germany, and in those countries was based on the then-new science of mendelian genetics. eugenicists developed research programs to determine the degree to which traits such as huntington’s chorea, blindness, deafness, mental retardation (feeblemindedness), intelligence, alcoholism, szhiophrenia, manic depression, rebelliousness, nomadism, prostitution and feeble-inhibition were genetically determined. eugenicists were also active in the political arena, lobbying in the united states for immigration restriction and compulsory sterilization laws for those deemed genetically unfit; in britain they lobbied for incarceration of genetically unfit and in germany for sterilization and eventually euthanasia. in all these countries one of the major arguments was that of efficiency: that it was inefficient to allow genetic defects to be multiplied and then have to try and deal with the consequences of state care for the offspring. national socialists called genetically defective individuals ‘useless eaters’ and argued for sterilization or euthanasia on economic grounds. similar arguments appeared in the united states and britain as well. at the present time (1997) much research and publicity is being given to claims about a genetic basis for all the same behaviors (alcoholism, manic depression, etc), again in an economic context – care for people with such diseases is costing too much. there is an important lesson to learn from the past: genetic arguments are put forward to mask the true – social and economic – causes of human behavioral defects.”
“From the very beginning, attention is given to the fact that, being introduced at the very beginning of the 20th century, the axiology term, meaning the doctrine of values, almost immediately led to a boom in the development of theories of values (mainly in continental philosophy), whereas the agathology term, meaning the doctrine of goods, which was introduced in 1770 and then rediscovered in 1823, came to almost complete oblivion. for its rehabilitation, one of the commonplaces of the philosophy of the 20th and 21st centuries is reviewed, namely, the actual identification of goods and values, as a result of which the former of these concepts is absorbed by the latter. as for values, they are also usually viewed as common human needs, rather than deep and indivisible individual ‘inner possessions’. therefore, it is proposed to distinguish between universal needs and personal valuables and to stratify the world of significant things into values, preferences, and goods. as a result, the latter of these varieties is interpreted as a sphere of practical mind (both in the ancient and kantian senses), teleologically loaded and with the potential to be included in a new, the fourth of the large programmes of theoretical ethics (able to compete well with consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics) and, at the same time, laid into the foundation of the cluster of philosophical disciplines, which is commonly termed as practical philosophy”
Greaves, H.. (2017). Population axiology. Philosophy Compass, 12(11), e12442.
“Population axiology is the study of the conditions under which one state of affairs is better than another, when the states of affairs in question may differ over the numbers and the identities of the persons who ever live. extant theories include totalism, averagism, variable value theories, critical level theories, and ‘person-affecting’ theories. each of these theories is open to objections that are at least prima facie serious. a series of impossibility theorems shows that this is no coincidence: it can be proved, for various lists of prima facie intuitively compelling desiderata, that no axiology can simultaneously satisfy all the desiderata on the list. one’s choice of population axiology appears to be a choice of which intuition one is least unwilling to give up.”
Vyzhletsov, G. P.. (2019). Ontological axiology: origins and modernity. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Philosophy and Conflict Studies, 33(3)
“The article analyzes the current state of ontological axiology in the context the problem of the source of values associated with being as it is relevant to the philosophical discipline. employing examples from the history of the doctrine of values’ formation, the author demonstrates that the source of values is being as whole. according to the author, ontological axiology is based on the unity of objective, subjective and transcendental levels of being, rather than on its individual components. formation of ontological axiology begins with works of nietzsche and concludes in the classical period of its history (1890s – 1930s), with developments of such outstanding philosophers of the 20th century as g. rickert, m. heidegger, m. scheler, n. hartmann, and n. о. lossky. during this period, the doctrine of the absolute character of values as ‘transcendental essences’ was developed. in this case, the values themselves are differentiated, as expressions of the subjective, objective or transcendental levels of being. ontological axiology as a philosophical discipline reaches a new level of development from the 1990s to the 2010s in opposition to the axiological relativism of philosophy and socio-cultural reality of the postmodern. from the standpoint of updated ontological axiology, the source of the objectivity of is the transcendental spirit (deitas) as the spiritual potential of the infinite universe. the life of the universe gives birth to man in the unbreakable unity of his body, soul and spirit. therefore, axiology together with the ontology and epistemology determines the specificity of philosophy and ways of its further development. refs.14.”
Hart, S. L.. (1971). Axiology–Theory of Values. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 32(1), 29.
“AXIOLOGY or theory of values is a relatively newndiscipline although valuational issues have been with usnthe moment man began to reflect upon conditions of hisnlife, the structure and uniformity of nature, and the questnfor the good life. valuational preferences are notnartifacts one can dispense with. inquiries into theirngenetic conditions, their truth and validity claims arenessential for any, reflective, principled conduct. man notnonly is engaged in valuational preferences, but he is alsonconscious of a scale of values, which scale rests with thendegree and quality of satisfactions. the great interest innaxiology at present has many reasons: the divorce ofnontological and valuational questions, the cultural gap,nthe gap between physical and humanistic studies, and thenliterary influence of brentano, ehrenfels, and meinong. thenarticle on ‘axiology’ deals with the major axiologicalnschools of thought: platonism, intuitionism, emotivism, andnnaturalism.”
Thomas, T.. (2018). Some Possibilities in Population Axiology. Mind, 127(507), 807–832.
“It is notoriously difficult to find an intuitively satisfactory rule for evaluating populations based on the welfare of the people in them. standard examples, like total utilitarianism, either entail the repugnant conclusion or in some other way contradict common intuitions about the relative value of populations. several philosophers have presented formal arguments that seem to show that this happens of necessity: our core intuitions stand in contradiction. this paper assesses the state of play, focusing on the most powerful of these ‘impossibility theorems’, as developed by gustaf arrhenius. i highlight two ways in which these theorems fall short of their goal: some appeal to a supposedly egalitarian condition which, however, does not properly reflect egalitarian intuitions; the others rely on a background assumption about the structure of welfare which cannot be taken for granted. nonetheless, the theorems remain important: they give insight into the difficulty, if not perhaps the impossibility, of constructing a satisfactory population axiology. we should aim for reflective equilibrium between intuitions and more theoretical considerations. i conclude by highlighting one possible ingredient in this equilibrium, which, i argue, leaves open a still wider range of acceptable theories: the possibility of vague or otherwise indeterminate value relations.”
ExplicationIn classical Greek mythology (i.e., Homer’s Iliad) myrmidónes were commanded by Achilles during the Trojan War. According to the legend Zeus created them from a colony of ants (myrmex). Cf. Sir Francis Bacon's metaphor on ants, spiders, and bees (Novum Organum Scientiarum, 1620). Per analogiam, ants are scientists who are rule conformist followers who lack the capacity to reflect (i.e., metacognitively/epistemologically) on what they actually do. They work myopically within a given Kuhnian paradigm without asking quintessential overarching questions and, ergo, without any awareness of the bigger picture.Quotation:Even entertainment can be politically of special value, because the moment a person is conscious of propaganda, propaganda becomes ineffective. However, as soon as propaganda as a tendency, as a characteristic, as an attitude, remains in the background and becomes apparent through human beings, the propaganda becomes effective in every respect.
Joseph Goebbels, Facism and the Female Form, 1942, p.170-71